Menu

The idea arrived on your walk. It began at your desk.

The Art of Thought · Graham Wallas, 1926

How Ideas Are Born is a 29-episode audio course on The Art of Thought, the 1926 book in which Graham Wallas, one of the founders of the London School of Economics, named the four stages of a new thought: preparation, incubation, illumination and verification. The complete book is beside it. Wallas shows where effort helps an idea along, and where it only gets in the way.

29episodes
153minutes of audio
4free episodes
2English and Ukrainian
The Art of Thought, Graham Wallas

The idea waited for the shower

All afternoon you sat with the client proposal. You reread the brief, opened three old decks, typed a heading and deleted it. Then, in the shower that evening, you saw it: the client never asked for more features, only for fewer steps. The idea took two seconds. It is tempting to decide that the afternoon was wasted and the shower did the work.

Graham Wallas saw both moments as parts of one process, and in 1926 he named its stages. He began with the physicist Hermann von Helmholtz, who told a banquet on his seventieth birthday that his best ideas had never come “when my mind was fatigued, or when I was at my working table,” but came readily “during the slow ascent of wooded hills on a sunny day.” They came, though, only after he had investigated the problem “in all directions.” Wallas called that first stretch Preparation, the time away Incubation and the arrival of the idea Illumination.

He added a fourth stage, Verification, from the mathematician Henri Poincaré, for whom an inspiration offers only “points of departure” for calculations that still have to be made. Wallas knew the pattern from his own life: his newest thoughts tended to arrive with “the first spongeful of water in my bath,” and he never found the courage to shop for a waterproof writing-tablet.

The Art of Thought, Graham Wallas

How Ideas Are Born

The first 4 episodes, free.

The introduction and the first lessons of the course, exactly as they sound in the app. No sign-up.

Introduction

Before a Thought Has Words

3 min
Lesson 1

Why You Cannot Order an Idea to Arrive

6 min
Lesson 2

A Question You Can Actually Work On

6 min
Lesson 3

Looking Is Not Yet Seeing

6 min

Keep going with The Art of Thought

The complete course has 29 episodes and 153 minutes of audio. One purchase per book, no subscription.

See all 29 episodes

The full course is coming to the App Store with Audeno.

What you will explore

A question the mind can work on

An email asking for “an interesting idea to improve efficiency” gives the mind nothing to hold. Asking colleagues where their time went yesterday gives it plenty. For Wallas, Preparation is real work: gathering knowledge, dividing up the field, adopting a definite “problem attitude.” The first three lessons, free to hear, follow a birthday speech, a vague brief at work and the front door of a small library until each one gives thought somewhere to move.

A pause with something in it

Helmholtz’s walks worked because the problem had already been investigated. Wallas also warned that the most dangerous substitute for real rest during Incubation is “the habit of industrious passive reading,” a habit that now fits in a pocket. The course compares two breaks, one of messages and short videos, one of a walk past an old cinema, and brings in later research: in a review by Ut Na Sio and Thomas Ormerod, the effect of a pause varied with the task and conditions, larger where preparation was longer and smaller where the break was filled with demanding mental work.

The moment before the answer, and the morning after

Wallas gave a name, Intimation, to the moment when you sense an answer coming before you can say what it is. It is fragile: it drifts off like a dream or breaks at the ring of a telephone. Words can scare it away, yet a little girl he quotes, told to be sure of her meaning before she spoke, answered: “How can I know what I think till I see what I say?” After it comes Verification, “with her lame foot and painful step.” The course follows a neighbors’ tool-sharing list that nobody used, one drill at a time, until it becomes an arrangement people feel comfortable with.

The important thing sends no reminder

In the most critical months of the war, the administrator Sir Warren Fisher began each day with his back to the fireplace, not yet looking at the urgent files on his desk, and asked the senior officials before him: “Now, you fellows, what is the most essential thing for us to get done today?” Wallas gathers habits like this one, from Dickens arranging ornaments on his table in a certain order to a friend who started work by copying out yesterday’s last few sentences, and insists that a thinker “must be the master and not the slave of his habits.”

Is this book for you?

  • You need a good idea by Friday, and the harder you push, the quieter your mind gets.
  • Your best thoughts arrive in the shower or on the stairs, and are gone before you find a pen.
  • By evening every message has an answer, and the question that matters is still untouched.
The Art of Your Own Thought29 episodes · 153 min
  1. ↗

    Before a Thought Has Words

    Introduction · 3 min · Meet Wallas and discover where the art of thought belongs in ordinary life.

    Free
  2. 01

    Why You Cannot Order an Idea to Arrive

    Lesson · 6 min · Why an order to invent can leave us stuck, and how we can help thought begin.

    Free
  3. 02

    A Question You Can Actually Work On

    Lesson · 6 min · Turn a vague assignment into a question the mind can work with.

    Free
  4. 03

    Looking Is Not Yet Seeing

    Lesson · 6 min · A library entrance reveals the difference between collecting information and noticing something.

    Free
  5. ❝

    A Thought on a Sunny Hillside

    Author’s words · 3 min · Wallas in his own words: Helmholtz, a sunny hillside, and the arrival of a thought.

    In the full course
  6. 04

    What Happens When You Step Away

    Lesson · 6 min · What an interval gives a prepared question, and why the kind of break matters.

    In the full course
  7. 05

    I Cannot Explain It Yet, but There Is Something

    Lesson · 6 min · Attend to the moment when an answer has not arrived, but something is beginning to form.

    In the full course
  8. 06

    From an Exciting Idea to Something That Works

    Lesson · 6 min · A neighborhood tool-sharing idea shows how verification continues the creative work.

    In the full course
  9. ↺

    The Table with No Room for Dinner

    Review · 4 min · One kitchen table brings the four stages together in a familiar story.

    In the full course
  10. 07

    Why One Thought Stays with You

    Lesson · 6 min · How a feeling of significance gives attention direction and keeps a question alive.

    In the full course
  11. 08

    Words You Can See Through

    Lesson · 6 min · A conversation about choosing a film reveals the creative power of understandable language.

    In the full course
  12. 09

    Finding Your Way Back into Yesterday’s Thought

    Lesson · 6 min · Find an entrance into yesterday’s work, and recognize when a familiar route needs to change.

    In the full course
  13. 10

    The Important Thing Sends No Reminder

    Lesson · 6 min · Why an important question disappears among urgent requests, and how it can enter the day.

    In the full course
  14. 11

    A Note That Comes Alive a Month Later

    Lesson · 6 min · A grandmother’s story emerges as separate memories begin speaking to one another.

    In the full course
  15. ❝

    How Scattered Thoughts Become a Whole

    Author’s words · 3 min · A complete passage on records, different working methods, and thoughts becoming a whole.

    In the full course
  16. 12

    Easy Words, but Is There Anything to Say?

    Lesson · 6 min · Fluent writing can grow from living skill or familiar repetition. What makes the difference?

    In the full course
  17. ↺

    The Story That Asked for Nothing

    Review · 4 min · Dmytro’s night-bus story brings attention, habits, notes, and energy into one undertaking.

    In the full course
  18. 13

    Minds Do Not All Take the Same Route

    Lesson · 5 min · A neighborhood celebration shows how principles and practical experience can work together.

    In the full course
  19. 14

    The Feeling of Certainty and the Thought Itself

    Lesson · 6 min · From the excitement of a hunch to understanding what we have actually found.

    In the full course
  20. 15

    The First Time You Speak for Yourself

    Lesson · 7 min · How an observation of your own helps you move beyond repeating someone else’s words.

    In the full course
  21. ❝

    A Place for a Future Thinker

    Author’s words · 3 min · Wallas imagines a school that protects individuality and makes room for a student’s future.

    In the full course
  22. 16

    A Room Where Thinking Is Possible

    Lesson · 6 min · How conversation, surroundings, and organization give a new thought a chance to be heard.

    In the full course
  23. 17

    Why Your Thought Needs the World

    Lesson · 6 min · For Wallas, the art of thought belongs to people, shared life, knowledge, and beauty.

    In the full course
  24. 18

    An Idea You Can Now Hand to Someone

    Lesson · 6 min · Follow Olena’s idea from an unclear assignment to something other people can use.

    In the full course
  25. ?

    When Ideas Have to Fit into Real Life

    Conversation · 6 min · A conversation about short intervals, fatigue, routine work, and ordinary rest.

    In the full course
  26. ?

    When There Are Too Many Ideas, or None

    Conversation · 6 min · What happens when knowledge is scarce, ideas multiply, notes pile up, or a good thought is forgotten?

    In the full course
  27. ?

    When Your Own Voice Is Still Quiet

    Conversation · 6 min · Speak for yourself, share unfinished work, and use feedback while preserving your own voice.

    In the full course
  28. ?

    When a Thought Needs to Become Finished Work

    Conversation · 6 min · Unsuccessful attempts, persistence, completion, and the moment a thought meets other people.

    In the full course
  29. ✓

    Your Thought Is Still Unfolding

    Closing · 3 min · Return to the unfinished thought and the room it leaves for your participation.

    In the full course

In the author’s words

A few lines from the book, kept in context: each one leads to its place in the text.

I find it convenient to use the term “Intimation” for that moment in the Illumination stage when our fringe-consciousness of an association-train is in the state of rising consciousness which indicates that the fully conscious flash of success is coming. A high English civil servant described his experience of Intimation to me by saying that when he is working at a difficult problem, “I often know that the solution is coming, though I don’t know what the solution will be,” and a very able university student gave me a description of the same fact in his case almost in the same words.

Voluntary abstention from conscious thought on any particular problem may, itself, take two forms: the period of abstention may be spent either in conscious mental work on other problems, or in a relaxation from all conscious mental work. The first kind of Incubation economizes time, and is therefore often the better. We can often get more result in the same time by beginning several problems in succession, and voluntarily leaving them unfinished while we turn to others, than by finishing our work on each problem at one sitting. A well-known academic psychologist, for instance, who was also a preacher, told me that he found by experience that his Sunday sermon was much better if he posed the problem on Monday, than if he did so later in the week, although he might give the same number of hours of conscious work to it in each case.

The art of thought, like the art of running, or the actor’s art of significant gesture, is an attempt to improve by conscious effort an already existing form of human behaviour. Men ran for countless generations before they invented or handed down the few expedients which constitute the art of running as taught by professional athletic trainers; they revealed their feelings by gestures long before there were any schools of dramatic art; and they thought for thousands of years before they had a name for thinking. In all these cases, therefore, the rules of art must be based on the most exact knowledge which we can obtain of the behaviour which the art is to modify.

The Art of Thought, Graham Wallas
The book

The Art of Thought

The Art of Thought is more than its four stages. Graham Wallas built it, as his preface says, on more than forty years as a teacher and administrator, and on accounts of their own thinking from poets, students and friends in England and America. From the stages he moves on to emotion and language, habit and effort, the ways professions and nations train the mind, and schools that leave room for a pupil’s own thought. At Shrewsbury, where he went to school, a saying of Dr. Kennedy’s was still handed down: “There is a great deal of Horace in this copy of verses, and a great deal of Vergil, but nothing horatian and nothing vergilian.” Wallas hoped his book would help “a few young thinkers in the practice of their art.” Audeno has the complete 1926 text and a full Ukrainian translation made for the app.

12 chapters · about 79,000 words

Read the whole book free

Contents
  1. The Art of Thought
  2. Preface
  3. Synopsis of Chapters
  4. Psychology and Thought01
  5. Consciousness and Will02
  6. Thought Before Art03
  7. Stages of Control04
  8. Thought and Emotion05
  9. Thought and Habit06
  10. Effort and Energy07
  11. Types of Thought08
  12. Dissociation of Consciousness09
  13. The Thinker at School10
  14. Public Education11
  15. Teaching and Doing12
  16. Index

Listen to this book’s course →

Graham Wallas

1858 to 1932

Graham Wallas was an English social psychologist and political scientist, one of the founders of the London School of Economics, where he taught for decades. He wrote on human nature in politics long before the subject had a name.

The Art of Thought, from 1926, is the book for which he is remembered today: its four stages of creative thinking, preparation, incubation, illumination and verification, remain one of the best-known accounts of how new ideas arrive.

Author page →

Get the full course

How Ideas Are Born: The Art of Thought

Free

  • The full text of the book
  • Every quote, with its place in the text
  • The introduction and the first three lessons
  • Texts offline; each lesson stays on your iPhone after its first play

Listen to the first lesson

Questions

What are the four stages of thought in The Art of Thought?

Wallas draws them from single achievements of thought, traced from beginning to end. Preparation: the problem is investigated “in all directions.” Incubation: you stop thinking about it consciously, by working on something else or by resting. Illumination: the “happy idea” appears, often announced by what Wallas calls Intimation, the sense that a solution is on its way. Verification: the idea is tested and given exact form. In the daily stream of thought, he adds, the four stages “constantly overlap each other,” so the course treats them as a map, not a ritual.

Is The Art of Thought only for artists and scientists?

No. Wallas draws on Helmholtz and Poincaré, but also on a preacher preparing a sermon, a civil servant at a difficult problem, an administrator choosing the day’s priority, and “a business man going through his morning’s letters.” The course stays with ordinary scenes: a birthday speech, a vague brief at work, a neighborhood exhibition, a kitchen table with no room for dinner. You do not have to call yourself creative. It is enough to want a thought of your own, not only a borrowed one.

Does the course draw on modern research?

Briefly, in two lessons, and only where it sheds light on Wallas. Benjamin Baird and colleagues (2012) found that people who spent a break on an undemanding task that let their minds wander improved more on unusual-uses problems they had already seen than some comparison groups. A 2009 review by Ut Na Sio and Thomas Ormerod found that the benefits of incubation varied with the task and the conditions. Marily Oppezzo and Daniel Schwartz (2014) found that walking helped people come up with varied, appropriate ideas, though not every kind of task benefited equally. The course presents these as parallels to Wallas’s account, with their limits, and keeps the focus on his book.

How long is the course, and what is free?

29 episodes, about two and a half hours in English: an introduction, 18 lessons of about six minutes each, three readings of Wallas’s own pages, two recaps, four conversations on the questions that may remain, and a short closing. In Ukrainian the course runs about 2 hours 45 minutes. The complete text in English and Ukrainian, the quotes, the introduction and the first three lessons are free in the Audeno app on iPhone. One purchase, 4.99 USD in the US and adjusted by country, opens the whole audio course in English and Ukrainian, and in any language added later. No subscription, and the course can be downloaded for listening offline.

What does the purchase open?

The complete audio course of this book, all 29 episodes, in every language it has now and every language added later. One purchase at the App Store price, $4.99 in the United States, adjusted by country. No subscription.

Can I listen offline?

Yes. Each lesson downloads the first time you play it and then stays on the iPhone; a course you own can be downloaded whole for listening with no connection. The text and quotes are inside the app.

Also in Audeno

The Art of Thought

How Ideas Are Born is a 29-episode audio course on The Art of Thought, the 1926 book in which Graham Wallas, one of the founders of the London School of Economics, named the four stages of a new thought: preparation, incubation, illumination and verification. The complete book is beside it. Wallas shows where effort helps an idea along, and where it only gets in the way.

Coming soon to the App Store. Until then, the free episodes and the full text of this book are here on this site.